49

1

sitting there and has daily contact with people, than it

2

would be for the appellate judge, who only sits as one

3

of a group, and only sits and listens to argument and

4

does not have to make decisions on the spur of the

5

moment. My own feeling leans towards having a shorter

6

terra for the trial court judge, not a longer term for

7

the appellate judge, but a shorter term for. the trial

8

judge because of the difference in the type of work that

9

he must do and which really is much more demanding,

10

physically weighing on a man than the appellate court

11

would.

12

THE CHAIRMAN: You might get into argument

13

on that.

14

MR. MARTINEAU: When he turns sour, the

15

results are much more disastrous. His partners on the

16

bench cannot cover up for him. The appellate court

17

can modify whatever his bad tendencies, might be. And

18

for that reason it seems to me there is a reason to

19

distinguish between the two.

20

MR. WINTERS: You are not talking now about

21

the proposed plans under consideration litre, but the